21 Comments
User's avatar
Phillip O'Reilly's avatar

It is hard to see the relevance of any economic agreements given the relentless malice of the Asian ' NATO ' scenario. Russia's Pacific fleet is a powerful deterrent, particularly of its submarine forces, the Americans would immediately use the southern Kurils to place sensors and weapons to blockade Russian bases. In Japanese-Russian diplomacy there is no Japan, just US. I really can't see how Japan can in anyway 'balance' China. China on any level is an existentially vital potential ally. Not only from its massive border but mutual intetests in the Eurasian centre and south. As an Australian I visit Japan and China and no longer think there is any sort of equivalence between them.

Kouros's avatar

This can properly work only after US leaves Japan. Until then the noose will continue to tighten around China & Russia. A compromise now will not bring any benefits to Russia. The US and therefore its proxies are agreement incapable. This state of increase heating will continue for the medium term (as Mr. Lavrov put it: 25-30 years) until some status quo will be reached, maybe. By then climate change effects will have affected everyone in some shape of form.

Alejandro's avatar

Russia does not have any reason to present 2 islands to Japan.

1956 and even early 2000 are a world of distance away.

Economic links are weak as hell as demonstrated with Europe, and anyway unnecessary and even prejudicial to develop your economy.

Russia has developed more in 12 years of strains or bull relations with the west than in the 24 previous years of relations.

Why would Russia renounce to two islands that are strategically crucial for them to keep the sea of okhotsk closed to enemy interference.

Two islands that anyway Japan does not have any real right to. Even the right of Japan to Hokkaido is very weak.

Japan likely will end this century losing Hokkaido and Okinawa.

The times where some genocidal western align countries were given a free pas to claim territory or morality are long gone.

Nobody with 2 cell brains today who woukd rule Russia would give those islands

Andrew Korybko's avatar

Shikotan and the Habomai Islands don't gatekeep the sea of Okhotsk, they're outer islands, unlike Kunashir and Iturup.

Phillip O'Reilly's avatar

Habomai is irrelevent. Shikotan is a potential base for monitoring exiting through the deep water channels of the main Kuril chain. Possibly as a site for sensor drones, alongside the many other means the US has available to attempt interdiction of course. The Chinese have a shallow water problem that Russia does not have with the Kurils. Anyway, any agreement is complicated by its tri-partite nature and the very unlikely scenario of Japan resisting US militarising Japanese territory.

Alejandro's avatar

They would not affect the sea being an internal Russian body of water in international terms but they would definitely weaken Russian position there. Some sonars there, radars and they movement of pacific fleet much easily monitor if they go out into the Pacific

Andrew Korybko's avatar

It wouldn't weaken Russia's position there in the list precisely because they're outer islands in very close proximity to Hokkaido, around which sonars, radars, and the like are already presumably established in Russia's direction facing the Sea of Okhotsk. It's likely for this reason that the USSR proposed giving them to Japan.

Andrew Korybko's avatar

The US' Aleutian Islands also play a much greater role in monitoring the Russian Navy's movement in and out of the Sea of Okhotsk than Shikotan and the Habomai Islands ever could.

Feral Finster's avatar

This assumes that anyone is interested in pursing their objective national insterests.

Russia wants to be liked. Japan wants to please the United States. The United States wants to hurt countries that are less than obedient (see, e.g. South Korea).

Mediocrates's avatar

Take the US influence out of Japanese politics and the Japanese economy and the Japan/Russia angst over the Kuril Islands will be resolved in no time.

Bindoner's avatar

So long as the US is a hostile regime there is no point making any deals with it's vassals. It is proven that their signature is valueless as their word, any treaty will be abrogated on a whim. Should Russia offer a compromise it would embolden the Empire.

Ray-SoCa's avatar

Putin's visit was sending a message. I don't see any chance in the near future of Japan reducing it's Russia Sanctions.

barnabus's avatar

I don't think peace treaties generally are worth the paper they are signed on, Declarations of neutrality - sure. Peace treaties - no.

Nakayama's avatar

Japanese elites need a war as much as their European counterparts.

Personally, I think Russia should buy out the Russian residents on the "four islands" north of Hokkaido and give the Japanese a feeling of "buffer space". But only those four islands. Such action poses minimal damage to Russia's national interests. Whether such gestures can buy a more peaceful attitude from the Japanese people is hard to say. But Russia can get some calmness in that area for a while. A flare-up, however, will come back again, because Japan behaves like an occupied nation. Whether Japan is truly an occupied nation does NOT matter. What matters is that the Japanese government behaves as one.

Walter DuBlanica's avatar

The Kutil begin in RESSIA and slime down as the come near Japan. S o the Kuril Islands are RUSSIAN . Japan you are the small guys. RUSSIAA are the BIG MEN.