Their fearmongering about impending Russian strikes on Poland, and especially the prime minister’s proposal for an “anti-ballistic missile coalition” with Ukraine, suggest that they want Poland to intercept Russian projectiles over Ukraine but first need to manipulate the president into authorizing this.
Europe wants war to cover for all their stupidity of the past. If they get that war, life will become extremely hard in Europe in no time. Only taking people like these to the gallows will dissuade others from this reckless path.
Both the European elite and public are unready for WWIII, and surely Tusk et al.—all rich people—do not want to spend their lives in cramped Patagonian bunkers. An all-out war would directly threaten their wealth and lives.
Incorrect, this is part of a master plan to destroy Europe, Russia, the US, the rest of the White world and the White race. Once one views things from this perspective events suddenly start to make complete sense.
If Poland is looking to intercept Russian drones and missiles over Ukraine it’s very quickly going to run into the same problems that Ukraine is facing.
Poland may still have some old Soviet legacy SAMs, but it pretty much relies on Patriots, which are like hens’ teeth atm, and seem to be only quasi-effective at best against advanced ballistic missiles.
Air to air missiles cost somewhere between $250k and $1m apiece, and relying on gunfire to shoot down drones is a risky business.
«Air to air missiles cost somewhere between $250k and $1m apiece»
Indeed and that is because both Cold War-era ground-to-air and air-to-air defenses were designed to be cost effective against airplanes costing $20m to $120m or more.
«and relying on gunfire to shoot down drones is a risky business.»
Many drones are weaker and slower than WW1 biplanes so well layered gun-based point defenses work well. Indeed a vast majority of drones get shot down and those who get through usually have limited payloads (often designed to just create big smoke plumes over damage). Problem is most armies have spent their budgets on tanks rather than on tank-protecting mobile platforms (which have always existed).
Bigger drones and cruise missiles are equivalent to pilot training aircraft (both propeller and jet powered) so they are more expensive and travel faster so they require small, cheap missiles but existing ones as mentioned above were designed for really expensive manned aircraft.
But there are two big political problems overall:
* The USA government regards as hostile any government (including vassal ones) that were to have the arrogance to develop their own strong anti-air defenses.
* Both the citizens of the RF and of the EU have a very, very strong preference for consumerism, and accordingly their governments prioritize butter over guns. The ukrainian government can do the opposite because ukrainian citizens have even less influence on policy than in the USA, EU, or RF.
Yes, although I meant gunfire from aircraft rather than ground based AA, as jet-powered drones and missiles fly above the effective ceiling of 25/35mm fire.
The risk is that a hit by a cannon shell could set off the explosive payload and damage or destroy the aircraft.
Many European intelligence heads (if not all civilian leaders) know that Russia has neither the will nor the means to invade, as shown by Poland's lack of investment in sealing its border, and those civilian officials who hype the threat are often of means, so they presumably know that WWIII rhetoric that actually comes to pass would be bad from a self-preservation viewpoint. I do not fully understand why people like Tusk, Sikorski, or Leyen want to risk their plush lifestyles on such a basis.
This was always the plan. Hence, Poland's "build up" by the EU since its "independence" from the Soviets. Why is the EU funding Poland's military expansion ? ;)
Andrew: You saying ruling liberals. However, isnt the Polish military full of nationalistic, "right wing" types. Wouldn't the ruling libs need to replace the officer corp of the Polish military with the same types that they put in charge of the US military during Obama's and Biden's terms ?
«Tusk’s announcement that Poland just joined Ukraine’s “anti-ballistic missile coalition” and Sikorski’s lobbying for Poland to intercept Russian projectiles over Ukraine hint at what they want.»
Another sign that the EU wanted a war with the RF would be truly enormous spending (some percent of GDP) on anti-air defenses, both for static and mobile targets, because *obviously* in a war the RF military would first target the main energy, transport and industrial assets of every enemy, even before targeting military objectives (the RF has strategic depth as the polish, swedish, french and german armies learned expensively).
This is obviously not happening. Contributing to the air defense of Ukraine is a much smaller undertaking because it matters a lot less to EU voters that the air defenses of Ukraine be leaky; presumably the goal is to just protect the military assets of Ukraine that kill russians more than protecting the industrial assets of Ukraine from RF retaliation.
The big question about "Poland to intercept Russian projectiles over Ukraine" is whether the interceptors would be based in Ukraine or in Poland. If the second case happens please remember that it has been amazing to have seen the many extraordinary developments in the first quarter of this century, too bad for the recently born :-(.
«conservative President Karol Nawrocki’s foreign policy spokesman accused him of pushing “a fabricated lie to electrify public opinion” [...] The ruling liberal coalition is less cautious [...] Their recent messaging might thus be an effort to precondition the public into accepting this escalation»
If the EU were really into starting a war with the RF they would be drafting young men, but a large majority of EU young men are only sons or even only children, so they cannot even be drafted. Probably mass immigration was also meant to have a supply of expendable young men (they and their mothers abroad cannot vote in the EU), but they are not enough to fill armies.
Consider the well publicized policy of german chancellor Merz of cutting pensions and welfare to fund higher military spending because of the russian threat it can be understood in two ways:
1) The goal is higher military spending and the means is cutting spending on pensions and welfare.
2) The goal is cutting pensions and welfare with the excuse of the russian threat.
The actual behaviour of the governments of Germany and other EU countries is clearly 2) because pension cuts are now and higher military spending is in the future, the actual amounts spent will be way below the planned amounts, and even the planned amounts are ridiculously small compared to what a war with the RF would need.
Note: a common strategy of politicians is to promise two stages of policy: the first stage is to take away something from some voters with the promise to give them something else in the second stage, but as a rule the first stage happens promptly and then the second stage is no longer necessary. When politicians want to do a policy for some sponsors they favor they do exactly vice-versa: they give them immediately something (for example a massive bailout) and promise to take something from them later (for example more restrictive rules) but the second phase somehow gets forgotten or watered down.
Also a large part of the planned EU military spending is about *offensive* weapons and this gives away the real policy: along with pension and welfare cutting there will be indeed *some* increase in military spending but it will be for weapons to send to proxies to kill as many russians as possible.
Europe wants war to cover for all their stupidity of the past. If they get that war, life will become extremely hard in Europe in no time. Only taking people like these to the gallows will dissuade others from this reckless path.
Both the European elite and public are unready for WWIII, and surely Tusk et al.—all rich people—do not want to spend their lives in cramped Patagonian bunkers. An all-out war would directly threaten their wealth and lives.
Ever see "Don't Look Up!"?
Incorrect, this is part of a master plan to destroy Europe, Russia, the US, the rest of the White world and the White race. Once one views things from this perspective events suddenly start to make complete sense.
It's almost like Europe's current leadership is on cocaine.
Oh wait...
If Poland is looking to intercept Russian drones and missiles over Ukraine it’s very quickly going to run into the same problems that Ukraine is facing.
Poland may still have some old Soviet legacy SAMs, but it pretty much relies on Patriots, which are like hens’ teeth atm, and seem to be only quasi-effective at best against advanced ballistic missiles.
Air to air missiles cost somewhere between $250k and $1m apiece, and relying on gunfire to shoot down drones is a risky business.
Polish threats sound like bs to me.
«Air to air missiles cost somewhere between $250k and $1m apiece»
Indeed and that is because both Cold War-era ground-to-air and air-to-air defenses were designed to be cost effective against airplanes costing $20m to $120m or more.
«and relying on gunfire to shoot down drones is a risky business.»
Many drones are weaker and slower than WW1 biplanes so well layered gun-based point defenses work well. Indeed a vast majority of drones get shot down and those who get through usually have limited payloads (often designed to just create big smoke plumes over damage). Problem is most armies have spent their budgets on tanks rather than on tank-protecting mobile platforms (which have always existed).
Bigger drones and cruise missiles are equivalent to pilot training aircraft (both propeller and jet powered) so they are more expensive and travel faster so they require small, cheap missiles but existing ones as mentioned above were designed for really expensive manned aircraft.
But there are two big political problems overall:
* The USA government regards as hostile any government (including vassal ones) that were to have the arrogance to develop their own strong anti-air defenses.
* Both the citizens of the RF and of the EU have a very, very strong preference for consumerism, and accordingly their governments prioritize butter over guns. The ukrainian government can do the opposite because ukrainian citizens have even less influence on policy than in the USA, EU, or RF.
Yes, although I meant gunfire from aircraft rather than ground based AA, as jet-powered drones and missiles fly above the effective ceiling of 25/35mm fire.
The risk is that a hit by a cannon shell could set off the explosive payload and damage or destroy the aircraft.
Many European intelligence heads (if not all civilian leaders) know that Russia has neither the will nor the means to invade, as shown by Poland's lack of investment in sealing its border, and those civilian officials who hype the threat are often of means, so they presumably know that WWIII rhetoric that actually comes to pass would be bad from a self-preservation viewpoint. I do not fully understand why people like Tusk, Sikorski, or Leyen want to risk their plush lifestyles on such a basis.
Both defer to the Americans. Yes, poland eventually will get sucked into the war.
This was always the plan. Hence, Poland's "build up" by the EU since its "independence" from the Soviets. Why is the EU funding Poland's military expansion ? ;)
Although, will Russia dare to fire on Poland when its going to be hosting the largest US base in Europe ? Computer says NO .
Andrew: You saying ruling liberals. However, isnt the Polish military full of nationalistic, "right wing" types. Wouldn't the ruling libs need to replace the officer corp of the Polish military with the same types that they put in charge of the US military during Obama's and Biden's terms ?
«Tusk’s announcement that Poland just joined Ukraine’s “anti-ballistic missile coalition” and Sikorski’s lobbying for Poland to intercept Russian projectiles over Ukraine hint at what they want.»
Another sign that the EU wanted a war with the RF would be truly enormous spending (some percent of GDP) on anti-air defenses, both for static and mobile targets, because *obviously* in a war the RF military would first target the main energy, transport and industrial assets of every enemy, even before targeting military objectives (the RF has strategic depth as the polish, swedish, french and german armies learned expensively).
This is obviously not happening. Contributing to the air defense of Ukraine is a much smaller undertaking because it matters a lot less to EU voters that the air defenses of Ukraine be leaky; presumably the goal is to just protect the military assets of Ukraine that kill russians more than protecting the industrial assets of Ukraine from RF retaliation.
The big question about "Poland to intercept Russian projectiles over Ukraine" is whether the interceptors would be based in Ukraine or in Poland. If the second case happens please remember that it has been amazing to have seen the many extraordinary developments in the first quarter of this century, too bad for the recently born :-(.
«conservative President Karol Nawrocki’s foreign policy spokesman accused him of pushing “a fabricated lie to electrify public opinion” [...] The ruling liberal coalition is less cautious [...] Their recent messaging might thus be an effort to precondition the public into accepting this escalation»
If the EU were really into starting a war with the RF they would be drafting young men, but a large majority of EU young men are only sons or even only children, so they cannot even be drafted. Probably mass immigration was also meant to have a supply of expendable young men (they and their mothers abroad cannot vote in the EU), but they are not enough to fill armies.
Consider the well publicized policy of german chancellor Merz of cutting pensions and welfare to fund higher military spending because of the russian threat it can be understood in two ways:
1) The goal is higher military spending and the means is cutting spending on pensions and welfare.
2) The goal is cutting pensions and welfare with the excuse of the russian threat.
The actual behaviour of the governments of Germany and other EU countries is clearly 2) because pension cuts are now and higher military spending is in the future, the actual amounts spent will be way below the planned amounts, and even the planned amounts are ridiculously small compared to what a war with the RF would need.
Note: a common strategy of politicians is to promise two stages of policy: the first stage is to take away something from some voters with the promise to give them something else in the second stage, but as a rule the first stage happens promptly and then the second stage is no longer necessary. When politicians want to do a policy for some sponsors they favor they do exactly vice-versa: they give them immediately something (for example a massive bailout) and promise to take something from them later (for example more restrictive rules) but the second phase somehow gets forgotten or watered down.
Also a large part of the planned EU military spending is about *offensive* weapons and this gives away the real policy: along with pension and welfare cutting there will be indeed *some* increase in military spending but it will be for weapons to send to proxies to kill as many russians as possible.