Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Regis Tremblay's avatar

Thank you Andrew for this excellent analysis.

Expand full comment
Erut's avatar

> our primary goal is to protect people that – let me repeat – feel like they are part of our nation, part of our culture.

"Humanitarian motivations" in exactly the same way that Nazi Germany took it upon itself to annex all territories where there were a significant number of German-speaking peoples.

> What was it when the centres of million-strong cities were struck from the air? What was it when troops with armour were deployed against them?

Every day we see again how Russia treats what it deems as "Russian" cities, in Kharkiv, in Kherson, in Bakhmut... Woe to the people being given such "humanitarian" aid -- The one thing worse than being an enemy of Russia is being a "friend" that won't let Moscow put its hand around your throat.

Muscovite Russia is an imperial entity, and has been for hundreds of years. But in Ukraine, it is losing. Badly.

> In this sense, they have achieved results, of course, and in this sense it has been something of a fiasco for us. We were left with nothing else. Maybe we were deliberately brought to this, to this brink. But we had nowhere to retreat, this is the problem...

This I fully support, and I hope the substack author continues to promote this propaganda. This fatalist reimagining of the disastrous Ukraine invasion is critical to set information conditions within the Russian populace and elites that will allow the Russian Empire to bring this "fiasco" to a close.

"We were forced into it". "We lost to the NATO/US/rest-of-world, not Ukraine". "Really, we still won (something)". This is the trinity of beliefs that once achieved in key parts of the Russian populace, will end this disaster. (2) is probably already at sufficient belief levels. (1) Putin is clearly working on here, and the substack author is thankfully helping. (3) is something the substack author has pushed repeatedly, but I do not ascertain is yet accepted in the Russian peoples that leadership is responsive too.

Expand full comment
13 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?