Article 5 doesn’t mandate the use of military force in support of an ally, and it certainly wasn’t meant to be exploited by false flags (or even genuine accidents) like Poland’s liberals seem to want to do.
I know I've already said this, often even, but now... I am truly, truly worried.
It seems that the entire European establishment, the plutocrats, their political and media lackeys, seem seized by a panic crisis in the face of the situation and especially the economic, social, and political prospects, and that, as usual in European history, they want to escape the immense tsunami composed of all the accumulated crises, through war. Or rather, they do not want war but want to make their population believe in it in order to allow a forced and totalitarian federalization of the EU, an unprecedented Orwellian restriction on public freedoms and individual rights.
The EU is collapsing under debt. Unlike the USA, it has no mineral or energy resources, and far from attracting brains, it attracts only the poorest and welfare profiteers from all the shit-holes of the world. It no longer creates intellectual patents, it is no longer intellectually audible. Its native demography is disastrous, its industry in tatters. Macron has a 16% approval rating, Merz 10, and almost the same in the UK. In Spain, for 10 years, illegitimate and arch-minority governments have been succeeding one another. In Italy, the hopes raised by the neo-fascist Meloni have collapsed in the face of hallucinatory inaction and incredible clumsiness.
All this little world seems in panic and sees only the militarization of the continent to save the furniture.
To this day, I find the situation far more worrying than it was at the beginning of the summer of 1914.
Putin keeps his calm. For how long?
I remain obsessed with this phrase from Putin and I would like our warmongers to keep it in mind, if indeed they know it:
"I keep from my childhood in the streets of Leningrad the principle that one must always avoid a fight as much as possible, but when it becomes inevitable one must strike first, fast, hard, and decisively."
I'm also extraordinarily worried and, just like you, I'm not one who's prone to exaggeration or hype up the threat of a major war. The most recent coordinated signals suggest that something very dangerous is being planned for the near future.
I believe that Putin will remain restrained and not authorize any cross-border strikes against NATO, but sabotage against some EU sites will certainly continue as Russia's delayed response to Western-backed Ukrainian sabotage and outright terrorism against Russia.
What I'm therefore most worried about is a false flag that leads to at least one NATO member initiating cross-border strikes against Russia (possibly Kaliningrad or maybe Russia's unrecognized New Regions, including Crimea), and then everything spiraling out of control.
Personally, what worries me most is, as in 1914, an event that none of the parties had sought, nor planned nor even anticipated, and a chain of events and miscalculations that no one controls anymore.
The rise to war in one month in 1914 is staggering in its stupidity and vanity.
The study of history shows that the greatest war cataclysms are never the result of a will but of poor assessments and a great deal of pride.
It's crazy to see people responsible for nations, even civilizations, behaving like schoolboys playing at who has the longest one.
While I do not doubt Putin's wisdom and patience, I do like Iran and Ansar Allah's way of drawing the red lines early and clearly and showing clear intention and capability to enforce the red lines. Of course, when one's country is too weak to enforce the red lines, it is better NOT to assert red lines. BUT, if a red line is ever asserted, a country must push hard to possess that capacity to enforce.
"I remain obsessed with this phrase from Putin and I would like our warmongers to keep it in mind, if indeed they know it:
'I keep from my childhood in the streets of Leningrad the principle that one must always avoid a fight as much as possible, but when it becomes inevitable one must strike first, fast, hard, and decisively.'"
The problem is that Russia has not done so, but dithers, fumbles around and makes excuses.
There's some sort of stoking conflict and crisis for sure...but to box it in with the constraints...it's either to talk tough or spark an internal crisis for some sort of political restructure. I just don't see a feasible path for hot war.
That said, if Russia really did have its eye on any of European territory, this might be just the time....but I don't think they want anything enough to deal with the hustle later.
«"when it becomes inevitable one must strike first, fast, hard, and decisively"»
This is not what happened in 2022: it was fast and decisive but the strike was not first (2014) and was not hard (tiny expeditionary force).
If as stated by Lavrov the RF forces pulled back voluntarily from Kiev as a "gesture of goodwill" towards the Istanbul negotiations the 2022 strike was not decisive either.
The other interesting phrase by Putin is "we have not started anything serious yet". It prompts the question whether the RF *can afford* to start something serious:
* There is always the issue common to RF and EU that most young men are only sons or only children.
* The middle classes of both RF and EU are extremely consumerist and Putin himself noted that a planned increase in military spending in the EU to 5% of GDP is a long way from what is needed for real war and a similar point applies to the RF.
«Slovak Prime Minister Robert Fico recently made headlines for telling his compatriots that he’ll do his utmost to keep their country out of war with Russia, including if it’s asked to participate in such a conflict through Article 5.»
Both our blogger and Fico are focusing on Article 5 of the North Atlantic Treaty but what really matters is Article 42(7) of the Treaty on European Union that says:
There is a huge difference between "taking [...] such action as it deems necessary" and "must assist it by all the means in their power".
If Fico refuses to honor article 42(7) to the full Slovakia will be suspended from the EU as fast as possible.
Article 42(7) is the reason why the ukrainian government is so keen on EU membership: Article 42(7) is in effect unlimited liability for the defense of any EU member by all other EU members and even if the ukrainian government stopped fighting the russians the rest of the EU would to still be committed to fight the russians "by all the means in their power" until the ukrainian 1991 boundaries are restored including Crimea.
Article 42(7) is also the reasons why the current governments of Sweden, Finland, the smaller baltics, Poland are so keen to organize anti-russian provocations and possible "incidents" on their territory; one of the important aspects of Article 42(7) is that it does not involve the USA at all. It would be incredibly fortunate for the USA MIC if the EU started a long attrition war with the RF in which the only role of the USA were as vendor ("Let's you and him fight").
«even if the ukrainian government stopped fighting the russians the rest of the EU would to still be committed to fight the russians "by all the means in their power" until the ukrainian 1991 boundaries are restored including Crimea.»
The mirage that the ukrainian government is trying to sell to ukrainian voters is that with EU membership and Article 42(7) all ukrainians will be able to move far away from the war to the richer EU countries and at the same time all other EU countries will have to fight to reconquer Novorossya and Crimea. A big win-win! :-)
What is going on is so obvious that even Sleepy Joe Biden "suggested to his aides that Zelenskyy might be deliberately trying to draw America into a third world war."
I know I've already said this, often even, but now... I am truly, truly worried.
It seems that the entire European establishment, the plutocrats, their political and media lackeys, seem seized by a panic crisis in the face of the situation and especially the economic, social, and political prospects, and that, as usual in European history, they want to escape the immense tsunami composed of all the accumulated crises, through war. Or rather, they do not want war but want to make their population believe in it in order to allow a forced and totalitarian federalization of the EU, an unprecedented Orwellian restriction on public freedoms and individual rights.
The EU is collapsing under debt. Unlike the USA, it has no mineral or energy resources, and far from attracting brains, it attracts only the poorest and welfare profiteers from all the shit-holes of the world. It no longer creates intellectual patents, it is no longer intellectually audible. Its native demography is disastrous, its industry in tatters. Macron has a 16% approval rating, Merz 10, and almost the same in the UK. In Spain, for 10 years, illegitimate and arch-minority governments have been succeeding one another. In Italy, the hopes raised by the neo-fascist Meloni have collapsed in the face of hallucinatory inaction and incredible clumsiness.
All this little world seems in panic and sees only the militarization of the continent to save the furniture.
To this day, I find the situation far more worrying than it was at the beginning of the summer of 1914.
Putin keeps his calm. For how long?
I remain obsessed with this phrase from Putin and I would like our warmongers to keep it in mind, if indeed they know it:
"I keep from my childhood in the streets of Leningrad the principle that one must always avoid a fight as much as possible, but when it becomes inevitable one must strike first, fast, hard, and decisively."
No one will be able to say they did not know.
I'm also extraordinarily worried and, just like you, I'm not one who's prone to exaggeration or hype up the threat of a major war. The most recent coordinated signals suggest that something very dangerous is being planned for the near future.
I believe that Putin will remain restrained and not authorize any cross-border strikes against NATO, but sabotage against some EU sites will certainly continue as Russia's delayed response to Western-backed Ukrainian sabotage and outright terrorism against Russia.
What I'm therefore most worried about is a false flag that leads to at least one NATO member initiating cross-border strikes against Russia (possibly Kaliningrad or maybe Russia's unrecognized New Regions, including Crimea), and then everything spiraling out of control.
Personally, what worries me most is, as in 1914, an event that none of the parties had sought, nor planned nor even anticipated, and a chain of events and miscalculations that no one controls anymore.
The rise to war in one month in 1914 is staggering in its stupidity and vanity.
The study of history shows that the greatest war cataclysms are never the result of a will but of poor assessments and a great deal of pride.
It's crazy to see people responsible for nations, even civilizations, behaving like schoolboys playing at who has the longest one.
One can easily guess which is the country of false flag.
Poland is the best candidate.
Baltes are too afraid to play this game. They worship barking but they are cautious.
A pole dreams of the day some American pats him on the head and calls him a good dog. A "real european" is the next best thing.
While I do not doubt Putin's wisdom and patience, I do like Iran and Ansar Allah's way of drawing the red lines early and clearly and showing clear intention and capability to enforce the red lines. Of course, when one's country is too weak to enforce the red lines, it is better NOT to assert red lines. BUT, if a red line is ever asserted, a country must push hard to possess that capacity to enforce.
The difference is that is directly USA which attacked Iran.
"I remain obsessed with this phrase from Putin and I would like our warmongers to keep it in mind, if indeed they know it:
'I keep from my childhood in the streets of Leningrad the principle that one must always avoid a fight as much as possible, but when it becomes inevitable one must strike first, fast, hard, and decisively.'"
The problem is that Russia has not done so, but dithers, fumbles around and makes excuses.
Or Poutine think that it's still possible not to fight.
Alas, I think that if he finally does it, it will not only a simple deterrence, but a big crushing one.
If Putin wanted to fight, he has plenty of reason already.
Russian timidity is why the war is coming. I hunt rabbits, songbirds and mice, not, say, racoons.
Can Europe really fight a war without diesel?
There's some sort of stoking conflict and crisis for sure...but to box it in with the constraints...it's either to talk tough or spark an internal crisis for some sort of political restructure. I just don't see a feasible path for hot war.
That said, if Russia really did have its eye on any of European territory, this might be just the time....but I don't think they want anything enough to deal with the hustle later.
«"when it becomes inevitable one must strike first, fast, hard, and decisively"»
This is not what happened in 2022: it was fast and decisive but the strike was not first (2014) and was not hard (tiny expeditionary force).
If as stated by Lavrov the RF forces pulled back voluntarily from Kiev as a "gesture of goodwill" towards the Istanbul negotiations the 2022 strike was not decisive either.
The other interesting phrase by Putin is "we have not started anything serious yet". It prompts the question whether the RF *can afford* to start something serious:
* There is always the issue common to RF and EU that most young men are only sons or only children.
* The middle classes of both RF and EU are extremely consumerist and Putin himself noted that a planned increase in military spending in the EU to 5% of GDP is a long way from what is needed for real war and a similar point applies to the RF.
I think Russia went to war with the army they had, not the army they wished they had...
I think that, at the idea that the "Germans are coming", the Russians will open the gates of hell and reach to the nuclear button.
Fico won't be given a choice.
Or he will be replaced.
Used: https://johndenugent.com/poland-readying-for-another-fun-war-with-tiny-little-russia-just-like-in-1939/
Once again, Poland is fueling Polish jokes, but some Polish jokes are not at all funny but tragic.
«Slovak Prime Minister Robert Fico recently made headlines for telling his compatriots that he’ll do his utmost to keep their country out of war with Russia, including if it’s asked to participate in such a conflict through Article 5.»
Both our blogger and Fico are focusing on Article 5 of the North Atlantic Treaty but what really matters is Article 42(7) of the Treaty on European Union that says:
https://eur-lex.europa.eu/EN/legal-content/glossary/collective-defence.html «When an EU Member State is the target of armed aggression on its territory, the other Member States must assist it by all the means in their power.»
There is a huge difference between "taking [...] such action as it deems necessary" and "must assist it by all the means in their power".
If Fico refuses to honor article 42(7) to the full Slovakia will be suspended from the EU as fast as possible.
Article 42(7) is the reason why the ukrainian government is so keen on EU membership: Article 42(7) is in effect unlimited liability for the defense of any EU member by all other EU members and even if the ukrainian government stopped fighting the russians the rest of the EU would to still be committed to fight the russians "by all the means in their power" until the ukrainian 1991 boundaries are restored including Crimea.
Article 42(7) is also the reasons why the current governments of Sweden, Finland, the smaller baltics, Poland are so keen to organize anti-russian provocations and possible "incidents" on their territory; one of the important aspects of Article 42(7) is that it does not involve the USA at all. It would be incredibly fortunate for the USA MIC if the EU started a long attrition war with the RF in which the only role of the USA were as vendor ("Let's you and him fight").
«even if the ukrainian government stopped fighting the russians the rest of the EU would to still be committed to fight the russians "by all the means in their power" until the ukrainian 1991 boundaries are restored including Crimea.»
The mirage that the ukrainian government is trying to sell to ukrainian voters is that with EU membership and Article 42(7) all ukrainians will be able to move far away from the war to the richer EU countries and at the same time all other EU countries will have to fight to reconquer Novorossya and Crimea. A big win-win! :-)
What is going on is so obvious that even Sleepy Joe Biden "suggested to his aides that Zelenskyy might be deliberately trying to draw America into a third world war."
https://www.ft.com/content/0da7d91d-6836-4fad-a636-740de2381ee6