Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Observateur's avatar

1) The F35A numbers will have to be adjusted by taking into account Russia's air defenses, more than capable to contain the on-paper superiority.

2) The Arctic environment should be organized Iran-style: fully underground, in beton and steel, whenever possible. Decoys may play an important role here.

3) Obviously the protection of the iceberg fleet is essential

4) The potential commercial damage is real and cannot be mitigated. Russia's idea of inviting her partners to participate in the exploitation of their Arctic territory is very good and might offer some commercial relief

5) If I were asked, I would recommend that all commercial and scientific vessels should navigate escorted by the Russian Navy, which should be prepared to shoot to kill at the first sight.

6) On the rest of it, one has to take into account if the NATO countries have or will have the necessary resources to create and maintain this superiority. Full of debt beyond their eyes, poor in resources, with a population in continuous effervescence, these countries are unlikely to pose a serious threat to Russia, as I see the economic situation in the EU and the UK that degrades almost on a daily base. Norway is by far the more capable to be a real threat, and I believe Mr. Karaganov will have some good advice on how to deal with her when it comes to it. The US will not move a finger for any of these pawns. They will always have the alternative to negotiate with the Russians.

Kennewick Man's avatar

The whole thing with ‘Golden Dome’ and all those F-35As sounds very romantic but the ultimate reality is still MAD and hypersonic missiles and submarines delivering first and second strikes never meeting an F-35A in the sky. As far as Golden Dome is concerned it is a giant task that requires endless new inventions and technological achievements. An actual solution can be most likely huge numbers of space based satellites with laser weapons, something that is nonexistent at this time. The reality is that it takes years to refill stock with top end missiles after the Ukraine, Iran conflicts and these conflicts are still active. I do not see the high tech capacity present in the US to produce Golden Dome or even a Silver Dome within a few years, maybe not even in five or more years.

22 more comments...

Ready for more?