Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Anton S's avatar

The substack author is right, 2022 has dramatically altered the way Russia will approach its geopolitical goals in the future. Because it has to change them. Because the invasion of Ukraine is a disaster.

The czar and his court are scrambling because they have to, and any port in a storm. The new grand vision is -- over time -- create a "third pole of tripolarity" that is built from the combination of Russian/Iran/India? Wow, what a fall from grace in just one year's time.

Russia envisioned itself as a "pole" unto itself, and this past year has laid that lie (thread)bare. The weaknesses economically and in all realms of soft-power were obvious to all, but the impression of Ru military power has been exposed as an unjustified holdover from Soviet times.

Can an alignment with Ru/Iran/India be a co-equal counterweight to the US? China? The EU?

What do the geopolitical goals and national values of these three pretend "allies" have in common? What do the people of these three "allies" have in common? Maybe some Russians and Iranians can bond over "Death to America" chants? Maybe India and Iran can bond over hating the same Sunni Muslim countries? The Soviets were a military arsenal for India at a delicate time in that country's history, but how long can that nostalgia effectively masquerade as an ongoing compatibility between these dramatically different countries?

Russia could have played between the EU and China, leveraging its other Central Asian relationships as a third axis of trade, and made trillions. But their "brilliant" leadership decided to invade Ukraine. So now it's Hail Mary time.

Nord Stream 1 & 2 were nice, but nah. Let's throw all our marbles in a much longer pipeline ove ra much less stable region, to a partner (India) that will pay much less for our (now) more expensively transported resources.

Geopolitically, Russia's transition to Canada has been dramatically accelerated by the disastrous Ukraine invasion. If only the Russian elites could embrace that and provide the fantastic standard of living to their people that Canada's incredibly enviable role in the world allows it to provide Canadians. Sorry Russians, more misery awaits because the czar wants an Empire.

Expand full comment
Tedder130's avatar

The author seems to downplay the profound strategic partnership of China and Russia when he exaggerates the importance of playing off so-called dependence on China with India, Iran, et al. Multipolarity implies good relations with these other countries, of which Iran is definitely on Empire's hit list. However, no alliance on the planet right now is as solid as the Sino-Russo partnership.

Expand full comment
6 more comments...

No posts