Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Geoffrey Maddocks's avatar

Norman Finkelstein has an interesting take on this, from this interview: "Prof. Norman Finkelstein: An Israeli Ground War Against Hezbollah Would Be A 'Catastrophe'"

..EXCERPT..

Israel is hoping it can knock out Lebanon by air. The Hezbollah strategy is perfectly obvious: they will keep shooting rockets at Israel; however, they're not going to let out a huge blitz. Every time Israel declares victory over Hezbollah, they will fire more rockets. Israel will then inflict more aerial destruction, declare victory, and then Hezbollah will fire more rockets in order to make the situation politically untenable for Israel. They'll have to launch a ground invasion. Now, if you listen to Nasrallah's last speech, he literally said, "Please invade, please invade. We welcome the invasion," which is true. Whether it's 100,000 or 75,000, the Party of God longs for, yearns for that invasion so they can finally settle the score with that satanic state, man to man, in hand-to-hand combat.

The Israelis dread the land war. Hezbollah longs for it, and the only way it can force the land war is to keep its rockets and missiles in reserve and deny Netanyahu the chance to declare victory. That's what happened in 2006. Israel amassed the troops on its border with Lebanon, and it wasn't until 72 hours before the 33-day war was over that Israeli troops entered Lebanon. Condoleezza Rice had already gotten a UN resolution through to end the war because Israel begged the US: "Get that resolution, get that resolution because we don't want the land invasion; it will be a disaster." And, speaking as a complete military know-nothing, speaking as a complete military ignoramus, I would say with 100% certainty, if it comes to pass, it will be a catastrophe for the state of Israel because those people have no fear, no dread of giving their lives to finally settling the score with that monstrous state that has inflicted so much death, destruction, agony, and anguish with all the haughtiness and arrogance of the Übermensch.

...

So the question is, how much death and destruction will Israel inflict from the air, and secondly, whether they will be forced to act because Hezbollah will deny Prime Minister Netanyahu the ability to declare victory. I should note that in the 2006 war, Hezbollah, on the very last day—on the 33rd day—fired more missiles and rockets than on any other day in that 33-day war. I think—correct me if I'm wrong—it was 10,000. Hezbollah wanted to transmit the message: "You lost." And I think they're going to do the same thing this time. They will hold back—that's my guess.

...

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=arUHCv1iXgk

chycho's avatar

Andrew, what are you talking about. You've been way off base on some of your previous analysis, but It's been interesting to read for at least an alternate take. This analysis though is in the realm of ridiculous.

Just because one side has no moral standing and is willing to commit war crimes and conduct genocide, it doesn't mean that they are winning the war. Also, as Vietnam showed us, one side can win almost every battle but still lose the war.

In short, just because Israel is killing more people doesn't make them the winner.

Also, the pager terror attack mainly killed and injured civilians, many of them healthcare workers, not the Hezbollah command structure. You couldn't even get this right. Not good, brother.

45 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?