11 Comments

Does Lula still have any plans on reviving the Sur? This is the only thing that could redeem him in my mind.

Expand full comment

It is a great American victory indeed. But I believe the RICS will keep their current alignment. Brazil also risks becoming isolated in Latin America - the coup in Peru was successful but I'm not seeing the same happening in other countries. You never know though.

Expand full comment

American Victory? We are América... They ARE nothing but Just f... usa...we are América, and We are Lula, our hero!

Expand full comment
Feb 24, 2023·edited Feb 24, 2023

Brazil will never be isolated from the rest of Latin America, as it is the largest regional economy. Despite all its difficulties, Mercosur with Argentina, Uruguay and Paraguay is a reality, as are plans for new highways through Peru, Bolivia, Paraguay and Chile so that Brazil can reach an outlet to the Pacific.

In the political field, there is an enormous coincidence between Lula and Amlo in Mexico, Alberto Fernández in Argentina and Gustavo Petro in Colombia; their reformist objectives are similar and the three countries promote its initiatives in forums such as CELAC, the Puebla Group and the Sao Paulo Forum.

Expand full comment

Thanks for the info.

Expand full comment

Lula, a giant!... Koribco who?

Expand full comment

Goodbye BRICS. Only SCO/SilkRoad and Trade Partners are priorities.

Expand full comment
Feb 24, 2023·edited Feb 24, 2023

As I pointed out yesterday when commenting on your article in response to the pseudo-left staunchly supporting Lula, the BRICS have sometimes raised expectations that are unrealistic at the moment.

Such is the case of Brazil, where Lula supports the creation of a new multipolar order, but is still subject to political, economic, technological and military dependence on Western imperialism, which limits his field of action in favor of his partners in the BRICS.

In Latin America, no one is really surprised by Brazil's vote at the UN; Mexico, Colombia, Argentina and Chile, other major countries in the region, also voted against Russia, with the notable exceptions of Bolivia, Cuba, Nicaragua and Venezuela, which shows that these are reformist governments, center-left, far from having a real will to break its ties with the US, the EU and its allies.

We have also seen this cynical and false behavior in the case of Mexico, where Amlo, a populist who one day criticizes the delivery of German tanks to Ukraine to satisfy his radical electorate in Mexico, the next day orders a vote in favor of resolutions as ignominious as yesterday in the UN General Assembly.

Expand full comment

As the saying goes, "Poor Mexico, so far from God, so close to the United States".

Expand full comment

Yep, it's a saying coined by the Mexican dictator Porfirio Díaz well before the Revolution that ended his regime in 1910.

Expand full comment

I'm not convinced. Yet another meaningless vote where everyone decided wether or not they are to be coerced into ostensibly agreeing with the US? Did the US care when almost the whole world (not the West's false narrative of "the world", I mean literally almost everyone) voted against Cuban sanctions yet again? No.

I think supply aid to Kiev would be a real backstab. Right now, it's just posturing.

Expand full comment